Cereal Thrilla – The High Performance Cereal Shootout

cereal review

Cereal Thrilla – The High Performance Cereal Shootout

Popular cereals in South Africa contain as much as 7 teaspoons of sugar per 100g serving – and that’s discounting the extra bit you throw over the top!

best cereal 07

SA’s most sugary cereal – source news24.com

 

Yep, that’s not a good sign, especially since studies have shown that kids in the US are consuming more than 4.5kgs of sugar annually from cereal alone – and South Africans luuurve their cereal

 

Breakfast is considered to be the most important meal of the day and it becomes important to ensure that we are putting the best stuff into our bodies, especially if you are leading an active lifestyle.

 

But, for most of us, finding the time each morning to prepare a proper cooked breakfast that is both high in protein and all the other good stuff is just not going to happen. It’s hard enough finding time to train regularly and most would rather spend that extra 20 minutes in bed – or, if like me, you always end up late for work because you tried to squeeze that extra YouTube vid in before getting dressed

 

As was done so valiantly in the No Sweat Antiperspirant Shootout, I took it upon myself to find the best High Performance Cereal to fill the void…in your stomach 🙂

 

So let’s get into it.

 

Test Methodology

 

In order for a cereal to qualify for the test, it had to meet the following criteria:

  • Could be found at any local supermarket,
  • Had at least 15g of protein per 100g (as per the label on the box), and
  • Required little to no effort to prepare (basically just add milk)

 

This revealed a few key players in the cereal game, namely: Jungle Ultra Energy, FutureLife Smart Food and the High Protein Smart Food, and Bokomo ProNutro.

 

best cereal 06

The contenders

 

Each cereal was tested using the following no-nonsense 4-step process:

  1. Throw portion into bowl
  2. Add full cream milk
  3. Mix with tablespoon
  4. Eat

 

I then scored each product out of 20. This was derived from attributing a score (out of 5) for each of the following categories:

  • Mixability (MIX) – things considered were time to prepare, lumpiness and the dreaded cement factor (how quickly the cereal tends to dry up)
  • Taste (TST) – things considered were the flavour and perceived palatability
  • Performance Factor (PFF) – although a very subjective measure, things considered were how long the product kept me feeling “full” and if I noticed any improvements in my performance
  • Protein to Carb Ratio (PCR) – a score was assigned based on the Protein:Carbohydrate ratio as follows:

1:2 = 5;                          1:3 = 4;                  1:4 = 3;                  1:5 = 2;                  1:5+ = 1

i.e. more points were awarded to cereals with higher protein and lower carbohydrates

 

Where the scores were tied, the Bang per Buck (i.e. cost per point) was used to distinguish between the ranks.

 

Now for the scores!

 

The Results (low to high)

 

best cereal 03

FutureLife Smart Food

  

FutureLife Smart Food

MIX – 3                 TST – 3                  PFF – 4                  PCR – 4                 Total – 14            RSP – R34.99

Comments – FutureLife has become synonymous with providing a healthy alternative to the usual sugar-filled cereals. At 16g of protein per 100g, it provides a decent serving of protein, but its downfall is its Mixability.

Unless, you have a whisk on hand or make it really really runny, you will be chewing on lumps of powder. It was also quite sweet, which meant I often followed a bowl up with a tall glass of water.

 

best cereal 05

Bokomo ProNutro (Wheat Free)

 

Bokomo ProNutro (Wheat Free)

MIX – 3                 TST – 4                  PFF – 4                  PCR – 3                 Total – 14            RSP – R33.99

Comments – The South African cereal legend!

I absolutely loved the taste of ProNutro. It wasn’t sweet, it mixed well and was a delight – all other brands should really take note of what Bokomo has managed to achieve with the taste of ProNutro.

The major downfall of the product was the dreaded cement factor which affected its Mixability score. It was a throwback to when I used to get ready for school and got caught up in the latest episode of Mina Moo.

 

 

By the time that intro ended, your spoon would be trapped tight enough for you to turn the bowl upside-down and not have any cereal fall out. So you best eat quick because this is still the case 🙂

 

best cereal 04

FutureLife High Protein Smart Food

 

FutureLife High Protein Smart Food

MIX – 3                 TST – 3                  PFF – 4                  PCR – 5                 Total – 15            RSP – R59.99

Comments – Although a bit pricey, this is my personal choice and I have included it in my diet lately. A great protein source that is quick to mix up – which is handy if you’re late for a meeting. It was also developed in conjunction with the University of Pretoria High Performance Centre, so it is ideal for use by athletes and if you have a high activity lifestyle.

 

However, it suffers from the same issues as the normal Smart Food version in terms of lumpiness and sweetness. I also found it to be a bit grainy towards the end.

 

best cereal 02

Jungle Ultra Energy

 

Jungle Ultra Energy

MIX – 4                 TST – 3                  PFF – 5                  PCR – 4                 Total – 16            RSP – R28.99

Comments – From the makers of Jungle Oats, comes a high energy cereal that takes the top spot on our review.

 

It delivers a similar Protein to Carbohydrate ratio as the FutureLife Smart Food, but mixes way better. However, like the FutureLife options, it is really sweet.

 

I found when I trained after eating this that I had a noticeable energy boost – probably due to the high carb content – so I will save this as my breakfast option before any big races in the future.

 

Summary

 

Although each box went down well, there had to be a winner. I admit this was no lab test in a controlled environment – these are real life findings i.e. tales from the dining room table.

 

I do think that there are some decent options out there albeit limited to a few products. I’ve already started rotating my usual Whey Protein + banana breakfast routine with some of these.

 

It would be interesting to see what other products come to market in the future – for a long time ProNutro was the only option available in South Africa.

 

Yes, there are the cereals that supplement companies like Biogen, Evox etc. have on offer, but you will need to visit Dischem or special order these off their websites so they are not as accessible to all consumers.

 

I do believe that there is still some way to go before we can replace a well thought out cooked breakfast with something off the shelves of a supermarket that has a great combination of Protein and Carbohydrates. But, if you find yourself rushing out and in need of grabbing something quickly, I’d keep one of these cereals handy.

 

Do you have any other products that work for you? Feel free to share in the comments section below.

 

– Peace

 

Fareed

fareed@leavethecouch.com
15 Comments
  • Aisha

    May 19, 2015 at 11:21 am Reply

    Thanks I found this informative.

    • Fareed

      May 19, 2015 at 1:56 pm Reply

      Hi Aisha

      Thanks for the feedback 🙂

  • Luqman

    May 19, 2015 at 2:36 pm Reply

    Pronutro wins. But only Banana flavour.

    • Fareed

      May 19, 2015 at 2:43 pm Reply

      I thought the chocolate flavour was really really good

  • bennie

    May 19, 2015 at 5:31 pm Reply

    Please test nutristart and nutristart active

    • Fareed

      May 19, 2015 at 8:36 pm Reply

      Hi Bennie

      I’ll go check it out and get back to you on it

      • Fareed

        September 17, 2015 at 10:43 am Reply

        Hi Bennie. I got some NutriStart Oats Smooth (chocolate flavour) for a quick test. Here are my scores:

        MIX – 3 TST – 1 PFF – 3 PCR – 3 Total – 10

        I’m not a big fan of the taste at all – I kept thinking it tasted like mud lol. It wouldn’t of made my initial cut because the Protein per 100g is only 11.2g. I think there are better (more tastier) options out there

  • Malikah

    May 20, 2015 at 9:00 am Reply

    Love the FutureLife chocolate flavour … especially if you do need that bit of sweetness in your life! Haven’t tried the Jungle Ultra before – thanks for review – will definitely head out to try it next !

    • Fareed

      May 20, 2015 at 12:34 pm Reply

      Chocolate FTW!

      Let me know what your impression of the Jungle Ultra Energy is after you’ve tried it

  • mufti

    May 26, 2015 at 3:15 pm Reply

    This was informative.
    Then you. All observations was noted and true.
    Education of the masses. Could you try post workout goodies?

    • Fareed

      May 26, 2015 at 4:23 pm Reply

      Hi Mufti

      Thanks for the great feedback!

      I’m sure I can cook up some supplement comparisons.

      Watch this space 🙂

  • Insaaf

    May 27, 2015 at 1:31 pm Reply

    Well done on your website Fareed! I have a chocolate protein pancake I make with oat flour (made like a flapjack) recipe you might like. I make a batch for the week and fry off 3 nice sized ones the night before and throw bananas, strawberries, bulgarian/greek yoghurt and honey on top. Keeps me full till after my lunch time gym session and it tastes super delicious I can actually eat it for every meal lol.

    • Fareed

      May 27, 2015 at 2:07 pm Reply

      Hi Insaaf

      That sounds AMAZING! I must try definitely try it out.

      Thanks for visiting LTC 🙂

  • Wayne

    August 31, 2016 at 11:23 am Reply

    Hi thanks for you’re info I run a swimming Squad and we have been using future life untill I spoke to a sports doc who told me to stay away from future life completely .I’m not going into detail but was advised maybe 1 helping every 6 weeks is ok as it was made for ppl who couldn’t put on wieght I’ve started using jungle oats ultra energy but it’s been to short to see a difference what’s your take on that ?

    • Fareed

      August 31, 2016 at 1:20 pm Reply

      Hi Wayne

      I’m no expert on nutrition, but shared what worked for me. I change what I eat all the time and usually go by ‘feel’ which isn’t very scientific at all.

      There are way too many factors to pinpoint what could be the right thing for you. I’d recommend you chat to a registered dietitian. Drop Adrian Penzhorn an email (adrian@foodforsport.co.za) he should be able to advise.

      Good luck

Post a Comment